Insurance and Business Protection: Safeguarding Your Pokemon Business

After 10+ years and one $3,000 loss from theft, I learned this expensive lesson: insurance isn't optional—it's essential. Most Pokemon sellers operate uninsured, risking catastrophic financial loss from theft, damage, liability, or disaster.

Let me show you exactly what insurance you need, what it costs, and how to protect your Pokemon business from devastating losses.

Why Insurance Matters for Pokemon Sellers

The Risks You Face:

• Inventory theft ($5,000-50,000+ inventory value at risk)
• Fire/flood/disaster destroying inventory
• Shipping losses (lost or damaged packages)
• Liability claims (customer injury, legal issues)
• Home business exposure (homeowners insurance may not cover business)

Real Story: Year 3, someone broke into my car and stole my card buying kit with $2,500 in cash and recent purchases worth $800. No insurance = $3,300 out of pocket loss.

After that: I got proper insurance. Cost: $300/year. Would have covered the loss minus $250 deductible.

Insurance is Cheap Compared to Losses

Types of Insurance for Pokemon Businesses

1. Business Property Insurance (Essential)

What It Covers:

• Pokemon card inventory (cards in your possession)
• Equipment (computer, printer, scanner, camera)
• Supplies (top loaders, shipping materials)
• Furniture (shelves, desk, storage)

What It Protects Against:

• Theft
• Fire
• Flood, water damage
• Natural disasters
• Vandalism

Who Needs It: Anyone with $5,000+ inventory value

Cost: $200-600/year depending on coverage amount

Coverage Amounts: Insure for replacement value of inventory

• $10,000 inventory = $10,000 coverage
• $50,000 inventory = $50,000 coverage

Where to Get It:

• State Farm Business Owner's Policy
• Nationwide Small Business Insurance
• Hiscox (online, easy)
• Progressive Commercial

My Coverage: $25,000 business property insurance through State Farm, $350/year

2. General Liability Insurance (Recommended)

What It Covers:

• Customer injury claims
• Property damage claims
• Legal defense costs
• Settlements/judgments

Example Scenarios:

• Customer slips at local card show booth (injury claim)
• Accused of selling counterfeit card (legal defense)
• Platform account hack, customer data compromised (liability)

Who Needs It: Anyone selling at events, handling customer info, or worried about legal claims

Cost: $300-800/year

Coverage Amounts: $1 million typical

Where to Get It:

• Same providers as business property
• Often bundled together (Business Owner's Policy)

My Approach: I have $1M liability insurance bundled with property insurance

3. Shipping Insurance (Case-by-Case)

What It Covers:

• Lost packages
• Damaged items in transit
• Theft by carrier

USPS Insurance:

• $50 included with Priority Mail
• Additional insurance: $1.65 per $100 value
• Claims process: File at post office

Third-Party Shipping Insurance:

• Shipsurance
• U-PIC
• InsureShip
• Often cheaper than carrier insurance

When to Use:

• Cards $50+ (always insure)
• Cards $100+ (insure + signature)
• Cards $500+ (insure + adult signature)

Cost: $0.50-2.00 per $100 of value

My Rule: Every shipment $75+ gets insurance

4. Inland Marine Insurance (High-Value Sellers)

What It Covers:

• Inventory in transit (driving to shows, carrying cards)
• Inventory at temporary locations (convention booths)
• Valuable inventory anywhere

Who Needs It: Sellers traveling with $10,000+ inventory

Cost: $500-2,000/year depending on coverage

Where to Get It: Commercial insurance brokers

Example: Traveling to convention with $20,000 inventory—this covers it while in car, at hotel, at booth

5. Cyber Liability Insurance (Advanced)

What It Covers:

• Data breaches
• Customer info theft
• Ransomware attacks
• Legal defense for cyber incidents

Who Needs It: Sellers with websites collecting customer payment info

Most Small Sellers: Don't need this (platforms handle payment processing)

Cost: $1,000-3,000/year

Homeowners/Renters Insurance: What's Covered?

Typical Homeowners Insurance:

• Covers personal property (including personal card collection)
• Usually does NOT cover business inventory
• Often has limits on business equipment ($2,500-5,000 typical)

If You Have $25,000 Inventory at Home:

• Homeowners insurance likely won't cover it (business use)
• Need separate business property insurance

Check Your Policy:

• Call insurance agent
• Ask: "Does my policy cover business inventory operated from home?"
• Usually answer is "No" or "Limited"

Don't Assume You're Covered

Umbrella Insurance (Personal Protection)

What It Is: Extra liability coverage beyond home/auto

Coverage: $1-5 million additional

Cost: $150-300/year

Why Consider: If Pokemon business is profitable and you have assets to protect

Not Business-Specific: But adds personal asset protection layer

Cost Breakdown: What Will Insurance Actually Cost?

Minimal Coverage (Part-Time Seller)

Business Property: $200/year ($10,000 coverage) Shipping Insurance: $50/year (occasional high-value) Total: $250/year

Moderate Coverage (Serious Part-Time)

Business Property: $400/year ($25,000 coverage) General Liability: $300/year ($1M coverage) Shipping Insurance: $200/year (frequent high-value) Total: $900/year

Comprehensive Coverage (Full-Time)

Business Property: $800/year ($75,000 coverage) General Liability: $500/year ($1M-2M coverage) Inland Marine: $1,000/year (travel coverage) Shipping Insurance: $500/year (frequent high-value) Total: $2,800/year

ROI: One major loss prevented pays for years of insurance

How to Get Business Insurance

Step 1: Inventory Your Assets

Calculate total value:

• Pokemon card inventory: $___
• Equipment (computer, printer, etc.): $___
• Supplies: $___
• Furniture: $___
• Total: $___

Step 2: Determine Coverage Needs

• Property coverage amount = Total value
• Liability coverage = $1M (standard)
• Shipping insurance = Case-by-case

Step 3: Get Quotes

Contact 3+ providers:

• State Farm
• Nationwide
• Hiscox (online)
• Progressive
• Local insurance broker

Provide:

• Business description ("Online Pokemon card sales")
• Revenue estimate
• Inventory value
• Coverage needs

Step 4: Compare and Choose

Look at:

• Coverage amounts
• Deductibles
• Exclusions
• Premium costs
• Claims reputation

Step 5: Purchase and Document

• Buy policy
• Save policy documents
• Set calendar reminder for renewal
• Update coverage as business grows

Claims Process: What to Do If Loss Occurs

Step 1: Document Immediately

• Take photos of damage/theft
• File police report (theft/vandalism)
• Gather receipts/proof of ownership
• List all items lost/damaged

Step 2: Contact Insurance Provider

• Call claims department immediately
• Provide policy number
• Describe incident
• Submit documentation

Step 3: File Claim

• Complete claim forms
• Provide receipts, photos, police reports
• Cooperate with adjuster

Step 4: Follow Up

• Respond promptly to requests
• Provide additional documentation if needed
• Track claim status

Step 5: Receive Settlement

• Review settlement offer
• Negotiate if lowball
• Accept payment
• Use to replace inventory/equipment

Pro Tip: Keep detailed inventory records (photos, receipts, values) updated. Makes claims process 10X easier.

What Insurance Doesn't Cover (Common Exclusions)

Typical Exclusions:

• Flood (need separate flood insurance)
• Earthquake (need separate earthquake insurance)
• Wear and tear
• Intentional damage
• War/terrorism (sometimes)
• Business interruption without property damage

Read Your Policy: Know what's excluded

Protecting Your Business Without Insurance

While you save for insurance or for low-value operations:

1. Diversify Storage Locations

• Don't keep all inventory in one place
• High-value cards in fireproof safe
• Offsite storage for backup inventory

2. Security Measures

• Home security system
• Cameras
• Safe for valuable cards
• Don't advertise inventory value publicly

3. Digital Records

• Photograph all valuable cards
• Store photos in cloud
• Keep receipts digitally
• Inventory spreadsheet backed up

4. Smart Shipping

• Always use tracking
• Insure high-value shipments
• Require signature on expensive cards

5. Safe Practices

• Don't carry large cash amounts
• Meet buyers in public places
• Secure inventory during travel

When to Increase Coverage

Increase coverage when:

• Inventory value grows significantly
• You start attending shows/conventions
• You hire employees/contractors
• You open physical location
• Revenue exceeds $50,000/year

Review Coverage: Annually or when major business changes occur

Action Steps

1. This week: Calculate total inventory and equipment value
2. This week: Check homeowners/renters policy for business coverage
3. This month: Get 3 quotes for business property insurance
4. This month: Purchase business insurance if inventory $5,000+
5. This month: Set up digital inventory documentation system
6. Ongoing: Always insure shipments $50+
7. Annually: Review and update coverage

Ready to Protect Your Business?

This is Module 5.5 of Week 5 in the Pokemon Business Startup Course.

Complete course includes:

• Insurance needs calculator
• Provider comparison worksheet
• Claims filing guide
• Inventory documentation templates
• Risk assessment checklist
• Insurance broker referrals

Enroll in the Pokemon Business Startup Course →

---

Module 5.5 of Week 5 - Pokemon Business Startup Course