Copyright, Trademark, and Legal Issues: Avoiding Pokemon IP Problems

After 10+ years selling Pokemon cards legally, I've learned this critical truth: Pokemon intellectual property (IP) is heavily protected, and violations can shut down your business instantly. Most sellers unknowingly violate Pokemon trademarks daily—risking cease and desist letters, account suspensions, or lawsuits.

Let me show you exactly what you can and can't do with Pokemon trademarks, how to describe cards legally, and how to protect yourself from IP issues.

Pokemon Intellectual Property: What's Protected

The Pokemon Company owns:

• Pokemon name and logo
• All Pokemon character names (Pikachu, Charizard, etc.)
• Pokemon artwork and images
• Pokemon card designs
• Trade dress (distinctive Pokemon card look/feel)

What This Means: You can't use Pokemon IP in ways that imply endorsement, affiliation, or authorization.

What You CAN Do (Legal and Safe)

1. Sell Authentic Pokemon Cards

100% Legal:

• Buy authentic Pokemon cards
• Resell them for profit
• This is "first sale doctrine"—once you legally purchase a copyrighted item, you can resell it

No Permission Needed from Pokemon Company

2. Describe Cards Accurately in Listings

Legal Use of Pokemon Names:

• "Charizard Pokemon Card for Sale"
• "Base Set Blastoise Holo Pokemon TCG"
• "Pikachu VMAX Ultra Rare"

Why This is OK: You're describing the product you're selling (nominative fair use)

Key: Must be accurate description, not misleading

3. Use Card Names and Set Names

Legal:

• Base Set
• Sword & Shield
• Scarlet & Violet
• Charizard VMAX
• Pikachu ex

These are product identifiers—legal to use in descriptions

4. Photograph and Show Actual Cards You're Selling

Legal:

• Take photos of physical cards you own
• Show front and back in listings
• Use your photos (not stock images)

Why Legal: You're showing the actual item for sale

What You CAN'T Do (Illegal or Risky)

1. Use Pokemon Logo in Branding

Illegal:

• Pokemon logo on business cards
• Pokemon logo on website
• Pokemon logo in social media profiles
• Pokemon logo on packaging

Why Illegal: Implies official affiliation or endorsement

Consequence: Cease and desist letter, account suspension, possible lawsuit

2. Claim Affiliation with Pokemon Company

Illegal Statements:

• "Authorized Pokemon dealer"
• "Official Pokemon seller"
• "Pokemon-approved business"

Unless True: You're NOT authorized (Pokemon doesn't have reseller programs for singles)

Legal Alternative: "Independent seller of authentic Pokemon cards"

3. Use Pokemon Artwork for Marketing

Illegal:

• Using Pikachu artwork on Facebook ad
• Using Charizard image as logo
• Using Pokemon card backs as branding

Why Illegal: You don't have license to use artwork for marketing

Legal Alternative: Use photos of actual cards you're selling

4. Create Knock-off Products with Pokemon Branding

Illegal:

• Custom "Pokemon" binders with logo
• Fake Pokemon cards
• Unlicensed Pokemon merchandise

Obvious but: Many sellers do this unknowingly

5. Use "Pokemon" as Your Business Name

Risky:

• "Pokemon Card Emporium"
• "Best Pokemon Sales"

Why Risky: Trademark infringement (using protected mark in business name)

Legal Alternatives:

• "Break Check Barragan" (unique name)
• "[Your Name] Trading Cards"
• "TCG Marketplace"

Then describe what you sell: "Specializing in Pokemon cards"

Counterfeit Cards: The Biggest Legal Risk

Selling Counterfeits is:

• Federal crime (trademark violation)
• Immediate platform ban
• Civil lawsuit risk
• Criminal prosecution possible

How to Avoid:

• Buy from reputable sources
• Learn to identify fakes
• When in doubt, don't sell it

If You Accidentally Sell Fake:

• Issue immediate refund
• Apologize
• Destroy card (don't resell)

Zero tolerance—protect yourself

Copyright Issues: Images and Content

Using Stock Images (Generally Not OK)

Don't:

• Download Pokemon card images from Google
• Use Pokemon Company's product photos
• Copy images from other sellers

Why: Copyright infringement

Do:

• Photograph your own cards
• Use your own images
• Get permission if using others' images

Describing Cards (Generally OK)

You Can:

• Write your own descriptions
• Describe card features, condition, rarity
• Use factual information

You Can't:

• Copy other sellers' descriptions word-for-word (plagiarism)
• Use copyrighted flavor text from cards as marketing copy

Trademark Fair Use: When You CAN Use Pokemon Names

Nominative Fair Use Doctrine allows you to use trademarks when:

1. Product can't be easily described without trademark
2. You only use trademark as necessary to identify product
3. You don't suggest sponsorship or endorsement

Example (Legal): "Authentic Charizard Pokemon Card from Base Set, excellent condition"

• Necessary to identify product
• Doesn't imply Pokemon Company endorsement
• Factually accurate

Example (Illegal): "Pokemon-Certified Charizard Card—Official Pokemon Quality Guarantee!"

• Implies false endorsement
• Misleading

Platform-Specific IP Rules

eBay IP Rules

eBay's VeRO Program (Verified Rights Owner):

• Pokemon Company monitors eBay for violations
• Report violations directly to eBay
• eBay removes listings immediately

Common eBay Violations:

• Using "Pokemon" in business name
• Counterfeit cards
• Misleading authenticity claims

Mercari IP Rules

Similar to eBay:

• Pokemon Company can report violations
• Mercari removes listings
• Multiple violations = account suspension

TCGPlayer IP Rules

Strictest enforcement:

• TCGPlayer very protective of relationships with rights holders
• Fast removal of violating listings
• Clear policies on authenticity

Protecting Yourself: Best Practices

1. Never Claim Affiliation

• Don't use "Official," "Authorized," "Licensed," or "Certified" unless true

2. Use Disclaimers (Optional but Helpful)

• "Not affiliated with The Pokemon Company"
• "All products are authentic and independently sold"

3. Photograph Your Own Inventory

• Don't use stock images
• Your photos = your copyright

4. Unique Business Name

• Don't use "Pokemon" in name
• Create distinct brand

5. Focus on Authenticity

• Only sell real cards
• Guarantee authenticity
• Refund if any question

6. Stay Current on Policies

• Pokemon Company updates IP policies
• Platforms update rules
• Check quarterly

What If You Get a Cease and Desist?

If Pokemon Company or Platform Contacts You:

Step 1: Don't Ignore It

• Respond promptly
• Take seriously

Step 2: Comply Immediately

• Remove offending content
• Stop violating behavior
• Acknowledge and apologize

Step 3: Consult Attorney (If Serious)

• If threatened with lawsuit
• If significant financial exposure
• Get legal advice

Step 4: Learn and Prevent

• Understand what you did wrong
• Implement changes
• Don't repeat

Most Cases: Resolve with simple removal of violating content. Pokemon Company typically sends warnings before legal action.

Common Misconceptions

Myth: "I'm small, they won't care" Reality: Pokemon Company protects IP regardless of seller size

Myth: "Everyone else does it, so it's OK" Reality: Widespread violation doesn't make it legal

Myth: "I can use Pokemon name because I'm selling their cards" Reality: Partly true (nominative fair use) but limits apply

Myth: "Fair use protects me" Reality: Fair use is narrow doctrine, doesn't cover most commercial use

Action Steps

1. This week: Audit your business name, logo, and branding (remove Pokemon IP)
2. This week: Review all listings for IP violations
3. This week: Add authenticity guarantees to listings
4. This month: Replace any stock images with your own photos
5. This month: Add disclaimer to website/profiles
6. Ongoing: Only sell authentic cards, never counterfeits

Ready to Stay Legally Compliant?

This is Module 5.4 of Week 5 in the Pokemon Business Startup Course.

Complete course includes:

• Trademark compliance checklist
• Legal listing templates
• IP violation response scripts
• Counterfeit identification guide
• Copyright compliance guide
• Attorney referral network

Enroll in the Pokemon Business Startup Course →

---

Module 5.4 of Week 5 - Pokemon Business Startup Course